Papa Joe’s Italian Cuisine

Reviews

• Tonya D.

  star star star star star 26 September 2026

  A must go to! I've lived in Lockport for two years and live across the street from Papa Joe's. Recently have placed two orders for their pizza which I must say was and is amazing! A must go to place because they don't short you on toppings and their prices are good! I will be making this a go to place every week! The staff here are very friendly and you will Not be disappointed if you order from here! Amazing pizza for sure!

• Dan H.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 23 September 2026

  Used to order from here all the time. However I will never do so again after today.
  
  Called to place an order and also to confirm they were still accepting orders. Was warmly greeted with "Papa Joes, hold". I held for 7 minutes. Some girl finally got on the phone and said "Hello, were no longer accepting orders tonight". I asked her if she was joking and she said no. I told her she could have not wasted my time and told me right when I called. She sarcastically replied that "sorry I was busy finishing something that's why I put you on hold"
  
  I told her we order from there all the time and asked for her name as I wanted to call the next day. She put me BACK ON HOLD and then said "I talked to the cook and we can still accept your order but cannot do any pizza or chicken" IS THIS A JOKE? I asked for her name one last time and SHE PUT ME ON HOLD AGAIN. Then some guy Jerry got on the phone who by the way has ZERO CUSTOMER SERVICE SKILLS and says they can now take my order but it can't be a stuffed pizza or chicken. I told him I just wanted their names to call back and speak to the owner as this was ridiculous. His reply was "ok, are you going to order?"
  
  I understand it was late but give me a break this was pathetic. Whoever I spoke to I pray you never work in customer service again as you are both horrible and a terrible representation of good business. Why am I so upset about this? Because you wasted my time and treated me like an idiot because you're lazy. Plenty of other pizza places in town that are 1000 X better.

• Tanisia C.

  star star star star_border star_border 20 September 2026

  It was just okay. I went after hearing about it from a family member who swears by it. The crust was okay but was a little thicker than I expected but was okay(they said it was thin crust). To me the sauce was pretty thin, which was a negative. Also it didn't have much cheese and seemed to be just thrown together.
  Pro: service was good.

• Nick S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 17 September 2026

  I guess 4.4 miles is out of their delivery zone. Seems like you might want to change that could have been a regular.

• A L.

  star star star star star_border 8 September 2026

  Small location, offering thin crust, pan and stuffed pizza. Plus sandwiches, pasta, salads, soup, wraps, appetizers, chicken, steaks, and seafood. Canned drinks and 2 liter bottles are available, no fountain drinks. There is a small seating/waiting area. But no booths or tables. Only a counter along the wall.
  The pizza I had was tasty and delicious